India under Lockdown – Center invokes Disaster Management Act to contain COVID-19. What happens to State orders?
The Indian Prime Minister, Mr. Narendra Modi,
while addressing the nation on March 24, 2020, announced a nationwide lockdown
for 21 days to contain the spread of COVID-19.
Shortly thereafter, the
National Disaster Management Authority (“NDMA”) issued an order dated
March 24, 2020 under the Disaster Management Act, 2005 (“DM Act”) noting
that it was satisfied that the country is threatened by the spread of COVID-19,
and that there is an urgent need to bring about consistency in the application
and implementation of various measures across the country while ensuring
maintenance of essential services and supplies (“NDMA Order”). To this
end, the NDMA directed that necessary guidelines be issued immediately.
Pursuant to the NDMA
Order, and in exercise of the powers conferred under Section 10(2)(l) of the DM
Act, 2005, the Ministry of Home Affairs, through the National Executive
Committee under the DM Act, issued an order dated March 24, 2020 (“Lockdown
Order”) for the
prevention and containment of COVID-19. The Lockdown Order will be operative
for a period of 21 days, with effect from March 25, 2020.
Under the Lockdown
Order, all States and Union Territories need to ensure strict implementation of
the guidelines set out therein, which can be accessed here.
The Lockdown Order
has effectively placed India under a nationwide lockdown for 21 days. In the
days leading up to the Lockdown Order, several State Governments had issued
orders notifying curfews and restrictions in their respective States for
containment and prevention of COVID-19 (“State Orders”). At the time of
writing, the State Orders have not yet been revoked by the respective States.
However, under Section 72 of the DM Act, the provisions of the DM Act will have
an overriding effect over any other law or instrument issued under any other
law for the time being in force. Accordingly, the guidelines issued under the
Lockdown Order will, to the extent of any conflict with the previous State Orders,
have an overriding effect. Therefore, all State Governments would need to
comply with the guidelines issued under the Lockdown Order.
That being said,
State Governments are also empowered under Section 38 of the DM Act to
undertake such further measures, over and above the guidelines issued by the
NDMA, they may deem necessary or expedient. Therefore, there is no restriction
on States to implement further or more stringent measure than those set out in
the Lockdown Order, provided such measures are not in conflict the Lockdown
Order. Accordingly, measures taken by State Governments under previous State Orders
will continue to have force, to the extent that they are not in conflict with
the Lockdown Order.
It
remains to be seen whether any State Government will implement further or more
stringent measures, given the variation in the impact of COVID-19 across
States.